Top Student

6 Feb


I recently found out that our grade school does not recognize the top student or valedictorian anymore.  They instead recognize all students with a GPA of 4.5-5.0 in their last two years of junior high.  Those students get a plaque.  This bothers me for two reasons.

1)  Obviously, I think my child IS the top student or valedictorian of the class.  🙂  Let’s be honest – that’s the number 1 reason.  He and another student are actually tied in GPA.  They are above the other students in their class because they are the only two students (in the history of the school, by the way) who will have TWO years of accelerated or honors high school math completed by the time they graduate from grade school.  These two students were tested in 6th grade by taking the high school placement test and scored in the 98% in the nation.  They were then placed into accelerated algebra at the high school in 7th grade.  Both received As for all quarters.  They are now in Accelerated Algebra II/Trig and are both receiving As for the two quarters completed so far.  Because these high school classes are honors classes, their GPA is weighted.  Therefore, the As these two students receive count more than the As that other students receive.

2)  The other reason that I am bothered by the “no-valedictorian-everyone-receives-a-plaque” rule is because As and Bs don’t really reflect top achievement anymore.  Here’s why I say that.

When our school publishes the HIGH HONOR ROLL and HONOR ROLL listings in the newspaper, over half of my son’s class is listed.  Over half!  Listed in the ranks of high honor roll are special education students and students taking classes below their grade level.  Again, no weighting.  An A is an A.

Our local newspaper just published an article saying that out of the 108 students expected to enter the freshmen class next year, 78  DID NOT test into high school level math (Algebra I) and 56 students DID NOT test into high school level English classes.


But over 1/2 of the kids are on high honor roll.

Receiving mostly As speckled with some Bs.

Do you see the problem?  What is an A worth these days?

In a neighboring town, a parent wrote in to an Open Forum column that the high school should not have all-school assemblies celebrating high scholastic achievement because it makes the other students “feel bad”.  This same high school is no longer going to acknowledge the valedictorian OR class rank.

Am I “old school”?  I find this a sad turn in our educational system…


2 Responses to “Top Student”

  1. bsburgess February 6, 2013 at 9:27 PM #

    And yet no one is cancelling pep rallys because it makes non athletic kids feel uncoordinated. Why can’t people see that it’s OK that their kid is not included in everything. It’s not about their kid, it’s about others who have feelings too and deserve recognition. Discriminating against the smart or bright kids sends the worst message. Education system needs to dump the low bar of mediocrity. This country is sliding into the ditch.

  2. Lee February 6, 2013 at 9:44 PM #

    Would I be incorrect to say it’s part of the ‘dumbing down of America’, and the attempts to equalize everyone, when clearly everyone is not equal? It reminds me of my son when he was taking Tee-Ball (peewee baseball), EVERYONE got a trophy and NO team won or lost, and likewise with his bowling, though they do give a ‘1st place’ trophy, everyone else – to keep from being left out – also gets a giant trophy with a little placard on that lists their high score. I personally find it ridiculous and wonder how any of this ‘esteem’ building creates a competitive desire for the future. I’ll get off my soapbox before I get in trouble! And even if he gets no reward, congratulations to your son and the other boy for the accomplishments they have made!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: